What We Can Learn from Singapore

SingaporeIn March of last year, my wife and I spent ten wonderful days in China as part of a group meeting with church and business leaders. It was an unforgettable experience. I told a group of Chinese students at a church service that I was bringing some of China back with me. Our hosts — from Hong Kong to Shanghai and Nanjing to Beijing — kept us well fed as I patted my stomach.

Economic growth is astounding. Cranes and skyscrapers were going up everywhere. How much of what is going on in China is an economic bubble that will soon burst, I cannot say.

In our many excursions by cars, vans, and buses, I got to speak to a number of Christian leaders who were filling us in on what’s going on in the Malay Peninsula and Indochina Peninsula regions, in particular Singapore and Vietnam. The economies in both countries are booming.

What’s happening in Singapore was the first to catch my attention. Most Americans know little about Singapore except for its punishment by caning. “A convicted male criminal who is between the ages of 18 and 50 and has been certified medically fit by a medical officer may be subjected to judicial caning.” Michael Fay was an American who gained international notoriety when he was sentenced to be caned as an 18-year-old in 1994 for theft and vandalism. He received four strokes across his bare buttocks.

There’s no doubt that the laws and customs of Singapore are different from the United States and other Western nations. The most interesting thing about Singapore is its economy. Consider the following:

Along with Hong Kong, South Korea and Taiwan, Singapore is one of the original Four Asian Tigers. The Singaporean economy is known as one of the freest, most innovative, most competitive, and most business-friendly. The 2011 Index of Economic Freedom ranks Singapore as the second freest economy in the world, behind Hong Kong. According to the Corruption Perceptions Index, Singapore is consistently ranked as one of the least corrupt countries in the world, along with New Zealand and the Scandinavian countries. . . .

The percentage of unemployed economically active people above age 15 is about 2%. Singapore has the world’s highest percentage of millionaire households, with 15.5 percent of all households owning at least one million US dollars. Despite its relative economic success, Singapore does not have a minimum wage, believing that it would lower its competitiveness.

Here’s what I found most interesting about Singapore’s economic philosophy. “The government has rejected the idea of a generous welfare system, stating that each generation must earn and save enough for its entire life cycle.” Even so, there are a number of “means-tested ‘assistance schemes’ provided by the Ministry of Community Development, Youth and Sports in Singapore for the needy.”

If there’s one thing we in the United States can learn from Singapore is its emphasis on self-government, planning for the future for ourselves and families and not to depend on money confiscated from other people.

email
Print Friendly

  • samtman

    The President of Singapore runs that City State of Singapore with dictatorial powers, the writer of this piece forgot to mention that Singapore has free halth care and takes care of its poor by finding jobs for them if they are able to work. Their income tax rate is one of the highest in world, but the Government is closely allagined with business and industry and spends large amounts of money on basic research and higher educatlion. If your smart enough to go to a famous foreign University, the Government will pay for it if you cant afford it. I do like some of those ideas like free health care, edication Government spending with business on research and training of workers. The writer fotgot to mention the poor pay, the long hours, the poor abhorent working condition of Chinas workers and loborers. The polution and the poverty in 80% of china.

    • John Wong

      But I thought that's what you want for US?

  • Brian

    "The highest income tax in the world" (Your words) = Free health cars??????

  • Don DeHoff

    Come on people. This little country, on one Island and several small Islets, is roughly 220 square miles with a population far less than the City of New York. That, combined with a abundant labor force from surrounding areas which receive very small wages, makes for a business paridise with about 20 percent being millionaires. Tax rates are very high and due to the low wage scales, it is the "worker bees" that are actually footing the bills.

  • Ah Beng

    By the looks of your spelling and writing abilities, I suggest you guys could use a little of Singapore's system.

  • Tank

    Roughly 4 million people living on an island about the size of a single medium US city, extremely low wage labor from Malaysia, Philippines, Vietnam, Indonesia, Thailand, etc. that get a work VISA/Employment card and living quarters built on the construction sites where they work, very high "sin" tax on alcohol/tobacco, one of the largest shipping hubs in the world, massive banking presence, technology companies investing there, zero tolerance laws on drugs and illegal immigration, and the list goes on. Having lived/worked in Singapore for a year, I've witnessed what keeps that place ticking, and it is solid business and neutrality. They worry about themselves instead of sticking their nose in the rest of the world's issues and welcome anyone and everyone to invest in Singapore. They have a fountain that the water sprays from the outside and flows inward to represent bringing into to Singapore. If you mess up there, you are dealt with swiftly and harshly, but when the people know that, it keeps them so much more on the straight and narrow. In a way, you feel more free and secure walking down a street at midnight in Singapore than any metropolitan city in the US. So, really, though they have somewhat of a dictatorship, who is more free, us, or them?

  • floyd

    obama talks of muslims and where he's from a MUST see for ALL Amedricans http://www.youtube.com/watch_popup?v=tCAffMSWSzY#

  • ThomNJ

    Agreed – I have been to Singapore many times – the writer of the article makes it a bit "fluffy" to say the least. – and the story about Michael Fay is a bit incomplete (and always was in the press). Fay's father is Singaporean and his mother is American. Fay was given a choice that if he wished to become an American at his legal age then he could and would nto be caned. His father told him that if he wanted to be a Singaporean (since that is really where he grew up) then he would have to accept being caned. The kid chose to become a Singaporean citizen; so he got caned.

  • Sidney Snott

    Don’t be daft. Singapore is suffering a population loss as a great many of its citizens have had enough and want out. The ruling party are known for bankrupting opposition politicians and stemming the flow of free speech. A British journalist was recently jailed for writing a critical book on the island state’s judicial process. There is not a real seperation of government and judiciary which is highly questionable to say the least. As for Michael Fay, there were many holes in the prosecution’s argument against him but that does not matter under a system like the one they have in that island. We cannot have simple minded people thinking that this system is somehow a way forward. The USA is said to be the champion of freedom and democracy and it is absurd that its citizens should look to such a place as some sort of beacon. Peopl need rights in employment, free speech, access to free media, to be able to air their views without fear of bankruptcy and a man needs to be able to travel in an elevator without living in fear that the stranger beside him, a woman will not accuse him of groping her bottom, after all, her word will always win and he will suffer a crual and humiliating punishment regardless of his innocence or guilt. If he accuses her of groping him, he can be sued in court by that woman. A pathetic and infantilising place that appeals only to the simple minded.